On November 12, 2025, at the U.S. Mint in Philadelphia, the last circulating penny rolled off the press. After 232 years, America stopped making its smallest coin. The reason sounds like a riddle: the one-cent coin had become far too expensive to be worth one cent.
The short answer
By fiscal year 2024, each penny cost the Mint about 3.69 cents to make and ship. Ten years earlier the figure was around 1.4 cents. Since a penny is only ever worth one cent, the government lost money on every single one it produced, and it was producing billions of them.
Doing the math on a losing coin
The gap between a coin’s face value and the cost of making it is called seigniorage. When the cost is lower than the face value, the government earns a small profit. When the cost is higher, seigniorage turns negative. Here is how that played out for the penny and nickel in FY2024:
| Coin | Face value | Cost to make (FY2024) | Loss per coin | Total seigniorage (FY2024) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Penny | 1¢ | 3.69¢ | 2.69¢ | -$85.3 million |
| Nickel | 5¢ | 13.78¢ | 8.78¢ | -$17.7 million |
You can check the penny figure yourself. The Mint shipped about 3.17 billion pennies that year. Multiply 3.17 billion by the 2.69-cent loss on each and you land at roughly $85 million, matching the official number. Pennies made up about 57% of all the circulating coins the Mint produced, so the most common coin was also the most unprofitable.
Why did it get so expensive?
A modern penny is not really a copper coin. Since 1982 it has been about 97.5% zinc with a thin 2.5% copper plating. Rising prices for zinc and copper, plus the fixed costs of running presses, transport and distribution, pushed the cost steadily upward. A coin with a tiny face value has no room to absorb that, because the materials alone can approach or exceed what it is worth.
Meanwhile, Americans were using cash less. Cash made up only about 14% of US payments in 2024, and an estimated 300 billion pennies were already sitting in jars, drawers and cash registers, far more than everyday commerce needs.
So what happens to prices now?
Pennies are still legal tender, and stores can keep pricing items to the cent. Card and other electronic payments are not affected at all. The change shows up only when someone pays in cash and the store has no pennies to give in change. In that case, the St. Louis Fed describes a common “symmetrical” rounding approach to the nearest five cents:
- Totals ending in 1, 2, 6 or 7 cents round down (for example, $4.97 becomes $4.95).
- Totals ending in 3, 4, 8 or 9 cents round up (for example, $4.98 becomes $5.00).
Because roughly half of cases go each way, studies suggest the effect on shoppers is tiny, measured in a few million dollars a year across the whole country.
The twist: the nickel is worse
If losing 2.69 cents per penny sounds bad, look again at the nickel. It costs nearly 14 cents to make a 5-cent coin, a loss of almost 9 cents each. The nickel’s total losses are smaller only because far fewer are minted. That is why the end of the penny has started a wider conversation about what coins should be made of and which ones the country still needs.
Key takeaways
- The US stopped minting circulating pennies on November 12, 2025, because each cost about 3.69 cents to make.
- Negative seigniorage on the penny cost the government about $85 million in FY2024.
- Pennies remain legal tender; only cash totals get rounded to the nearest five cents when no pennies are available.
- The nickel loses even more per coin, costing about 13.78 cents to make.
Sources
- U.S. Mint: Historic ceremonial strike for final production of the circulating one-cent coin (Nov 12, 2025)
- Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis: When a Penny Costs More Than a Penny (May 2026)
- CoinNews: Penny costs 3.69 cents to make in 2024, nickel costs 13.78 cents
- U.S. Mint: Penny media kit and coin specifications
Curious which coin goes next? Watch the short above and subscribe to FindThinkLearn on YouTube at youtube.com/@findthinklearn for more bite-sized stories about money and the economy.