Did Mansa Musa Really Crash the Price of Gold?

Can one person give away so much gold that gold itself gets cheaper? The internet’s favourite answer involves Mansa Musa, the ruler of the Mali Empire, who passed through Cairo in 1324 on his way to Mecca. The story is true at its core. The dramatic version, though, goes further than the evidence does.

What happened in Cairo

Musa ruled a West African empire rich in gold, and his pilgrimage made that wealth impossible to miss. Our best-known account comes from al-Umari, a Damascus-born scholar who wrote about the visit roughly twelve years later and spoke with officials who had dealt with the king.

According to al-Umari, Musa sent loads of unworked gold to the royal treasury and gave a load to every court emir and royal office holder. His party also spent heavily in the markets, and Cairo’s traders made large profits buying, selling and exchanging gold with them.

The maths of a falling gold price

Cairo priced gold in silver. A mithqal was a set weight of gold, and a dirham was a silver coin. Al-Umari says a mithqal had not gone below 25 dirhams before Musa came, and afterwards did not exceed 22. Here is what that means for a made-up trader:

Before (25 dirhams) After (22 dirhams) Change
100 mithqals of gold sells for 2,500 dirhams 2,200 dirhams -12%
1,000 dirhams of silver buys 40 mithqals about 45.5 mithqals +13.6%

This is plain supply and demand. When far more of something arrives in one market and demand stays about the same, each unit fetches less. A 12% fall is painful for anyone holding gold, but it is a long way from gold becoming worthless, so “crash” is a strong word for it.

How much gold was there?

Nobody knows. Britannica reports a baggage train of 80 camels carrying 300 pounds of gold each, while other retellings put the load per camel as low as about 50 pounds.

Load per camel Total for 80 camels In metric tonnes
50 pounds 4,000 pounds about 1.8
300 pounds 24,000 pounds about 10.9

That is a sixfold gap, and historians treat these figures as storytelling rather than accounting. The same caution applies to the huge modern dollar estimates of his fortune, which have no solid medieval basis. For scale, you can compare any of these numbers with all the gold ever mined.

The part historians argue about

The popular claim is that Cairo’s gold market stayed depressed for twelve years. That detail rests on al-Umari alone. Historian Warren Schultz, who studied Mamluk exchange rates, points out that other chroniclers of the period do not back it up.

In his 2006 reappraisal, Schultz found that gold usually traded at around 20 dirhams per gold coin in the early 1300s, a figure that does not line up neatly with al-Umari’s, and that rates moved up and down for many reasons. He calls the dip after Musa’s visit “one of many short-term fluctuations”. So gold probably did get cheaper for a while, but a lasting collapse is doubtful.

The twist on the way home

The king who handed out so much gold ran short himself. Several medieval writers say he had to sell goods and borrow from merchants at high rates. Ibn Battuta names an Alexandrian merchant, Siraj al-Din ibn al-Kuwayk, as lending him 50,000 dinars, and accounts differ on whether the lenders were ever fully repaid.

Key takeaways

  • Even gold follows supply and demand. Its price is always relative to something else, here silver.
  • Percentages tame a legend: 25 to 22 dirhams is about a 12% drop.
  • One vivid source can become “fact” through repetition, so check how many independent records support a claim.
  • For a far more extreme case of too much money, see Zimbabwe’s 100 trillion dollar note.

Sources

Enjoy history with a twist of economics? Watch the short above and subscribe to FindThinkLearn on YouTube at youtube.com/@findthinklearn.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top